Big Mistakes, a new comedy series created by Dan Levy, the mastermind behind the beloved Schitt's Creek, is a fascinating exploration of the challenges that come with creating a follow-up to a groundbreaking show. While it may not be a masterpiece, it showcases Levy's talent and provides a glimpse into the complexities of the entertainment industry.
Levy, who co-created Schitt's Creek with his father, Eugene, brings his signature wit and charm to Big Mistakes. The show follows Nicky, a nervous pastor, and his sister Morgan, a cool school teacher, as they navigate a series of misadventures involving a real diamond necklace and a criminal gang. The premise, while not entirely original, is a vehicle for Levy's comedic genius.
One of the most intriguing aspects of Big Mistakes is the exploration of the dynamics between the characters. Levy excels at portraying the psychological regression that occurs when adult siblings reunite. The bickering, the parent-based in-jokes, and the opportunity to be honest and slightly horrible to each other without social repercussions are all hilariously captured. The relationship between Nicky, Morgan, and their other sister, Natalie, is a delightful portrayal of sibling rivalry and affection.
The cast of Big Mistakes is a testament to the show's success. Laurie Metcalf, who plays the trio's overbearing mother, delivers a masterful performance, swinging between steely authority and fragile vulnerability. Taylor Ortega, as Morgan, is hilarious and stylish, and the dynamic between her and Levy's Nicky is a joy to watch. The show's aesthetic, with its jerky camerawork and abrasive score, adds to the tension and stress of the family dynamics.
However, Big Mistakes is not without its flaws. The organized crime caper subplot feels generic and fails to live up to the potential of the premise. The final twist, while surprising, lacks the depth and coherence that would make it a satisfying conclusion. The show's reliance on clunky and implausible developments to prolong the gangland underworld scenes is a missed opportunity.
Despite these shortcomings, Big Mistakes is a watchable and entertaining show. It showcases Levy's ability to create relatable and engaging characters, and the exploration of family dynamics is a refreshing take on the domestic cringe comedy genre. While it may not be a triumph, it is a testament to the talent of its creator and a fascinating insight into the challenges of creating a follow-up to a successful show.
In the end, Big Mistakes is a safer bet for a risk-averse TV industry, but it is a testament to the power of a star's vision. It may not compete with the ensemble productions that turn unknowns into household names, but it is a reminder that sometimes, a star's creation can still shine brightly, even if it doesn't quite reach the heights of its predecessor.
